Can I Sue the Other Driver Even If the Insurance Company Offers a Settlement?

An insurance adjuster calls with a settlement offer for your accident. A sense of relief washes over you, quickly followed by a nagging question. Can I still sue the other driver? You’ve been through a lot since the accident, and now you face a choice about that offer.

You generally can take legal action against the at-fault driver, even if their insurance company offers a settlement, as long as you haven’t accepted the offer and signed the paperwork.

If you’re pondering whether you can sue the other driver even if the insurance company offers a settlement, there are some points to consider.

Get A Free Consultation

Understanding the Insurance Company’s Settlement Offer

Receiving a settlement proposal often brings a mix of emotions. It’s a step forward, yet it prompts questions about its fairness and your next steps. Gaining clarity on what the offer signifies is a positive first action, and a personal injury lawyer can explain your legal options.

What an Initial Offer From an Insurer Really Means

An initial settlement offer from an insurance company is its first attempt to resolve your claim. It’s a proposal, not a final statement of what your claim is worth. The first offer often reflects the insurer’s assessment of your damages based on the information they have.

Insurance adjusters work for the insurance company. Their job is to settle claims efficiently and usually for the lowest amount that seems reasonable from their perspective. You’re not required to accept this first offer, especially if you feel it doesn’t cover all your losses from the accident.

Considering whether to sue the other driver after this initial settlement offer is a valid consideration, and your lawyer can walk you through the specific advantages you may have by filing a suit.

Why Insurance Companies Sometimes Offer a Low Settlement

Insurance companies sometimes present settlement offers that seem too low. One common reason is that the insurer is trying to protect its financial interests. They aim to pay as little as possible on claims to maintain profitability.

Another reason for a low offer is that the insurer might not have a complete picture of your injuries or losses. They might undervalue aspects like your pain and suffering or future medical needs if you haven’t fully documented these.

Some insurers might make a low offer to gauge whether you’re willing to accept less than you deserve or are prepared to challenge them. Advice from an attorney is particularly helpful when it comes to evaluating settlement offers.

If you believe the settlement proposal is insufficient, exploring other options, such as formally rejecting the offer and preparing to sue the driver, becomes a pathway to consider.

Your Right To Pursue Legal Action After Receiving a Settlement Offer

Even when an insurance company presents a settlement figure, you retain the right to pursue a lawsuit against the at-fault driver. Whether it’s wise to sue the driver after the insurance company offers a settlement depends on your specific circumstances and whether the offer meets your needs.

Grounds for Suing the Other Driver After an Insurance Offer

You might consider suing the other driver if the settlement offer doesn’t fully compensate you for your injuries and losses. If the amount proposed doesn’t cover your medical expenses, lost income, future care, or pain and suffering, a lawsuit might be a way to seek adequate compensation.

If you’re unsure of the value of your claim or even the extent of your injuries, consult with an attorney to learn more. They’re well-practiced in calculating damages and offer protection from low offers.

Another ground for suing is when there’s a significant dispute over who was at fault for the accident, and you believe the offer unfairly reflects this dispute. Sometimes, the insurer makes an offer assuming a certain percentage of fault on your part that you disagree with.

Suing after the insurance company makes a settlement offer becomes a path to argue your case for full compensation based on the other driver’s complete responsibility.

What Happens to the Initial Offer if You Consider Suing?

If you reject the insurance company’s settlement offer and explore a lawsuit, that specific offer is typically off the table. Once rejected, it’s gone. However, rejecting an offer and indicating your intent to sue does not always end settlement discussions.

Frequently, the negotiation process continues, and the insurance company might come back with a higher offer once they see you’re serious about litigation and are prepared to take your case to court.

Key Factors When Deciding to Sue

Choosing to reject a settlement offer and pursue a lawsuit involves careful thought. It’s a decision with potential benefits but also some risks. You must weigh several elements to determine the best course of action for your situation.

Looking at Your Total Losses, Not Just Current Bills

A fair settlement covers all your accident-related damages, not just the medical bills you’ve received so far. It’s important to account for the accident’s impact on your life. You have to calculate past, current, and future losses before deciding if suing after an insurance settlement offer is necessary.

Think about these different types of damages:

• Medical Expenses: This compensation includes hospital stays, doctor visits, medication, physical therapy, and any anticipated future medical treatment.
• Lost Income: This payment covers wages you lost while unable to work and also your diminished earning capacity if your injuries prevent you from earning the same income as before.
• Pain and Suffering: This compensates for physical pain, emotional distress, and the overall negative impact on your quality of life.
• Property Damage: This payment covers the costs to repair or replace your vehicle or other personal property damaged in the accident.
• Emotional Distress: This compensation addresses the psychological impact of the accident, such as anxiety, fear, and sleep disturbances.
• Loss of Consortium: In some cases, a spouse may be entitled to compensation for the loss of companionship, support, and intimacy due to the other spouse’s injuries.

Potential Benefits

Choosing to sue the other driver after a settlement offer has potential advantages, primarily the possibility of receiving a larger compensation amount through a court judgment or negotiation. Insurance companies may take your claim more seriously when a lawsuit is filed.

Another advantage is that the legal process allows your attorney to gather more evidence from the other side, potentially strengthening your case. For some, holding the at-fault party accountable in court provides a sense of closure.

Possible Drawbacks

Suing the other driver also comes with potential downsides. Lawsuits take time; they often last months or even years before resolving. Additionally, there’s no guarantee of winning a lawsuit. If the court sides with the other driver, you might receive nothing or less than the original settlement offer.

Time Limit for Filing a Lawsuit

States have a specific deadline for filing a personal injury lawsuit, known as the statute of limitations. For most car accident cases in Florida, you typically have two years from the accident to file a lawsuit (or four for property damage). In Washington, the deadline is generally three years.

Missing this deadline means you lose your right to sue the other driver for your injuries, regardless of the strength of your case or how inadequate any prior settlement offer was.

Therefore, if you’re considering suing the other driver even after the insurance company offers a settlement, be mindful of this time limit and contact an attorney immediately.

How a Lawyer Helps You Fight for a Fair Settlement

When an insurance company offers a settlement and you’re unsure if it’s fair or if you should sue, a lawyer provides valuable assistance.

Navigating the complexities of insurance claims and personal injury law is challenging. An attorney acts as your advocate, helping you make informed decisions when proceeding with legal action against the other driver.

Assessing the Fairness of an Offer

A personal injury lawyer evaluates all settlement offers in the context of your specific accident and injuries. They compare the proposed amount to what similar cases have resolved for and assess whether the insurer’s offer is reasonable or if you need to seek more compensation based on your losses.

Calculating the Full Extent of Your Damages

Lawyers are skilled in identifying and calculating all forms of damages you suffered, including current and future medical costs, lost wages, loss of future earning capacity, and non-economic damages like pain and suffering.

Leading Negotiations

An experienced car crash attorney takes over communications and negotiations with the insurance company. Adjusters often use specific tactics to minimize payouts, but lawyers know how to counter these tactics and negotiate effectively for a better settlement on your behalf.

Their involvement often signals to the insurer that you’re serious about getting fair compensation.

Clearly Outlining Your Legal Choices

Your lawyer explains your legal options from the start in straightforward terms. They outline the pros and cons of accepting the current offer versus pursuing a lawsuit. They answer your questions and provide the information you need to decide your path forward.

Starting a Lawsuit and Representing Your Interests

If you decide that suing the other driver is the right course, your lawyer handles the entire legal process. This includes filing the necessary court documents, gathering evidence through discovery, dealing with the opposing counsel, and representing you in all court proceedings.

Keeping Track of Important Deadlines and Paperwork

A lawyer manages all the administrative and procedural requirements for you. They file all paperwork correctly and on time, especially critical documents like the summons and complaint.

FAQ for Can I Sue the Other Driver Even If the Insurance Company Offers a Settlement?

How Do I Know if the Settlement Amount Offered by the Insurance Company Is Fair?

Determining if a settlement offer is fair involves comparing the offered amount against the total extent of your damages: all your medical bills (past and future), lost income, lost earning ability, property damage, and your pain and suffering.

An offer that barely covers current bills but ignores future needs or your suffering is likely unfair. A personal injury attorney helps by evaluating offers against similar case outcomes and the full calculated value of your claim.

If I Turn Down the Insurance Offer, Is My Only Option to Sue the At-Fault Driver?

No, suing the at-fault driver isn’t your only option if you reject an insurance offer. Declining an offer often leads to further negotiations. Your lawyer may present a counter-demand to the insurance company, explaining why their offer is insufficient and detailing the amount you believe is fair.

Many cases settle through these continued discussions, without needing to go to trial. A lawsuit is a tool to use if negotiations stall and a fair agreement isn’t reachable.

If I Sue, What Other Compensation Might I Get That Isn’t Included in My Current Offer?

A lawsuit might allow you to recover a broader range of damages or higher amounts than what an initial insurance settlement offers. These damages may include more comprehensive compensation for future medical care, especially if your injuries require long-term treatment or lead to permanent conditions.

You might also receive a more accurate valuation for lost earning capacity if your ability to work is permanently affected.

Additionally, you may win a higher sum for non-economic damages like pain, suffering, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life, which insurance companies often undervalue in initial settlement offers.

How Much Time Do I Have To Decide if I Want to Sue the Other Driver After a Car Accident?

In Florida, the statute of limitations for personal injury claims, including those from car accidents, is generally two years from the accident (or four years for property damage). In Washington, you usually have three years.

There are exceptions to these deadlines, and waiting too long to consult an attorney and decide whether to file a suit might mean losing your right to seek compensation through the courts, regardless of any prior settlement offers.

What Are My Options if the Insurance Company’s Settlement Proposal Doesn’t Cover All My Medical Costs?

If the insurance company’s settlement proposal doesn’t cover all your current and anticipated medical costs, you can reject it. Your attorney can negotiate a higher amount that fully addresses your medical expenses and other damages.

If negotiations don’t work, your attorney can file a lawsuit against the at-fault driver to seek the full compensation to cover all your medical treatments and other related losses.

Take Control: Secure the Compensation You Deserve

The moments after an accident are uncertain, and an insurance company’s offer might seem like the only path. However, you have choices, and knowing your rights is the first step toward achieving a fair outcome.

If you’re considering suing the other driver even though the insurance company offered a settlement, call Boohoff Law, P.A. Our team is ready to review your situation and discuss your options.

Call us at (813) 445-8161 for a free consultation to help you move forward.

Get A Free Consultation