Lowball Offer for Your Totaled Car? What To Do When Your Car Was Totaled and the Insurance Offer Seems Too Low

The news that your car is a total loss is bad enough. Then, the insurance company makes a settlement offer, and your heart sinks a little more. If your car was totaled but the insurance offer seems too low, don’t panic. You don’t automatically have to accept a low settlement offer.

You have options to show that your car was worth more. Many people face this situation when a car is totaled and the insurance offer is too low. A car accident lawyer offers protection from lowball offers and other insurance tactics.

Get A Free Consultation

Understanding the Insurance Company’s Offer for Your Totaled Car

When an accident happens and your vehicle suffers heavy damage, the insurance company starts a process. They look at the repair costs and compare them to your car’s value before the accident. This leads to their settlement offer.

Sometimes, the settlement for your totaled car might feel much lower than you expected. A low offer for your totaled car isn’t the final word.

What Does “Totaled” Mean Anyway?

A car is considered a total loss when the cost to repair it is more than a certain percentage of its actual cash value. This percentage varies by state and by insurance company.

Essentially, the insurer decides it’s not financially sensible to fix your car. They’ll pay you what they think your car was worth right before the accident.

How Insurers Determine Your Car’s Value

Insurance companies usually use a system to find your car’s Actual Cash Value (ACV). The ACV is not what you paid for the car; it’s what it was worth just before it got damaged.

Insurers look at the year, make, model, mileage, and overall condition. They also search for recent sales prices of similar cars in your area. If this ACV seems incorrect, it might be why your car totaled insurance offer is too low.

Common Reasons for Lowball Offers on Totaled Vehicles

An insurance offer for a totaled car sometimes seems too low for several reasons. For example, the adjuster might use outdated market data or compare your car to vehicles in worse condition or with fewer features.

If your insurance offer is too low for your totaled car, specific issues might be at play. Insurance companies use valuation reports from third-party vendors. These reports aren’t always perfect. They can miss important details about your car.

This oversight often leads to an unfairly low insurance offer for your totaled car. Reviewing their assessment carefully helps find these errors. Pinpointing these problems is a key step when dealing with a low total loss offer.

Special Features or Upgrades

Your car might have had options or add-ons that increased its value, such as a sunroof or custom wheels. If these weren’t standard for your car’s model, the insurer might not include them in their initial calculation.

Recent upgrades add value, like new tires or a major engine part. Check if these upgrades are listed in the insurer’s report.

Common examples include:

• Custom Sound System: High-end stereo installation and speakers add value.
• Recent Major Replacements: Putting on new tires or replacing a significant component like the transmission boosts your vehicle’s ACV.
• Special Edition or Trim Packages: Manufacturer upgrades or packages not included in the base model are often overlooked by insurers during the valuation.

Comparable Vehicles That Aren’t Really Comparable

Insurance companies find the value of your totaled car by looking at comparable vehicles or “comps.” Comps are similar cars recently sold in your area. The problem arises when the chosen comps are not truly like your car.

Comps might be base models when yours was a higher trim level. They could have more miles or be in poorer condition. If the comps are unsuitable, the ACV for your vehicle might be too low, making your totaled car insurance offer too low.

Your Car’s Excellent Condition Was Ignored

The condition of your car right before the accident greatly impacts its value. If you kept your car in excellent shape, with a clean interior and a well-maintained engine, it may be worth more than your offer. Insurance adjusters often miss this level of care.

Insurers frequently assume cars are in average condition unless shown otherwise. The offer will likely be low if the insurance report lists your car’s condition as fair or average when it was actually pristine.

Providing proof of its superior condition can make a difference when your car’s totaled value is simply too low.

Review the Valuation Report

The insurance company provides a valuation report that explains how it arrived at its offer. Go through it line by line and look for errors in your car’s description, mileage, options, and condition.

Check the comparable vehicles they used. Are these vehicles genuinely similar to yours? Make notes of any mistakes or questionable comparisons. A low settlement offer for your totaled car often stems from inaccuracies in this report.

Find Your Own Comparable Vehicles

Don’t rely only on the insurance company’s comps. Do your own research. Look for vehicles of the same make, model, year, and trim as yours that recently sold or are currently for sale in your local market.

Look for vehicles in similar or better condition with comparable mileage. Online car sales sites and local dealer listings are good resources. This evidence helps when your car totaled insurance offer seems too low and you need to counter.

Gather All Your Car’s Records

Your records are evidence of your car’s value and condition. Collect everything you have that shows its history and upkeep. These documents provide a factual basis for a higher valuation of your totaled car.

Give these documents to your lawyer. They can help demonstrate that their initial assessment of your totaled car value is too low.

• Maintenance Logs: These papers show you performed regular oil changes, tire rotations, and other services, indicating your car was well-maintained.
• Repair and Upgrade Receipts: Proof of new parts, major repairs, or aftermarket additions shows investments that boosted the car’s condition and value beyond the average.
• Original Window Sticker or Bill of Sale: These documents list all your car’s options and packages when new, which the insurer might have overlooked.

Get A Free Consultation

How a Lawyer Helps You After a Lowball Offer on Your Totaled Car

Sometimes, despite your best efforts, the insurance company might not offer a fair amount for your totaled car. Car accident lawyers understand insurance companies‘ tactics and how to counter them.

Reviewing Your Insurance Policy Details

An attorney can examine your insurance policy. They look at the exact coverage you have for a total loss. They find terms or conditions that affect your claim for the totaled car.

Understanding the policy’s fine print is where they can pinpoint your rights if the offer seems too low. This review identifies how the insurer should calculate your settlement.

Assessing Your Car’s True Market Value

Lawyers often work with independent appraisers or valuation services who objectively assess your car’s true market value before it was totaled. This independent valuation provides strong evidence to counter a low insurance offer for your totaled car.

This assessment offers a credible alternative to the insurer’s possibly flawed calculation.

Compiling Evidence for Your Claim

An attorney helps gather and organize all documentation needed to support your claim that the insurance offer for your totaled car is too low. This includes repair records, photos, purchase documents, and expert opinions.

Lawyers know what evidence is most persuasive and present it effectively to the insurance company.

Insurance Communications and Negotiations

Dealing with insurance adjusters is challenging when your car’s totaled value is in dispute. A car crash lawyer takes over these communications and negotiates for a fair settlement on your behalf. Their experience in these talks is a benefit when facing a lowball offer for your totaled car.

Explaining Your Legal Options

If negotiation doesn’t result in a fair settlement, a lawyer can explain your options, which might involve mediation, arbitration, or filing a lawsuit. They outline the pros and cons of each path.

FAQ for What if My Car Was Totaled but the Insurance Offer Seems Too Low?

How Do Insurance Companies Decide a Car Is a Total Loss?

Insurance companies declare a car a total loss when the cost to repair it plus its salvage value exceeds its actual cash value (ACV) before the damage occurred. Some states have a specific percentage threshold; if repair costs reach, say, 75% or 80% of the ACV, it’s deemed a total loss.

The insurer calculates the repair estimate and compares it to your car’s pre-accident market value to make this decision. If they decide it’s a total loss, they offer a settlement.

What Kind of Proof Helps Show That My Car Was Worth More?

Several types of proof demonstrate that your car was worth more than the insurance offer. Detailed maintenance records show that your car was in excellent condition. Receipts for recent major repairs or upgrades, like new tires, a new engine, or an enhanced stereo system, add value.

Photos of your car before the accident, showing its pristine condition, also help. Comparing prices of similar cars with higher values in your area can help show that the insurance offer for your totaled car was too low.

What if My Car Was Totaled and I Still Owe Money on the Car Loan?

If your car was totaled and you have an outstanding loan, the situation becomes trickier. The insurance payout goes to the lender first to pay off the loan. If the offer is less than what you owe, you’re responsible for the difference. This is known as a “gap.”

If you have GAP insurance, it typically covers this difference. If not, and you believe the totaled car insurance offer is too low, it’s even more pressing to negotiate a higher settlement to reduce or eliminate that gap.

How Long Does It Take To Get a Fair Settlement for My Totaled Car?

The time it takes to settle a total loss claim varies based on the facts and other factors. If you accept the initial offer, it might take a few weeks. It will take longer if you dispute the low offer for your totaled car and negotiate.

Gathering your evidence, submitting it, and going back and forth with the adjuster adds time. Working with an attorney improves your chances of receiving a fair settlement, but it may take longer. There’s no set timeline, but persistence with good evidence often leads to progress.

Do I Have To Accept the Insurance Company’s First Total Loss Offer?

No, you don’t have to accept the insurance company’s first offer for your totaled car, especially if you feel it’s a low settlement offer. The first offer is just that—an initial offer. You can review it, ask questions, and negotiate if you have evidence that your vehicle was worth more.

A car accident lawyer can advise you of your options and help build a strong case.

Secure a Fair Value for Your Car

When an insurance offer doesn’t seem to reflect your car’s true worth, remember that the first figure isn’t always the final one. You can question a low settlement offer and work towards a better outcome.

If you’re grappling with a low insurance offer for your totaled car, you don’t have to navigate this alone. The personal injury lawyers at Boohoff Law, P.A. understands these challenges and knows how to fight back against lowball offers.

For guidance on your total loss claim and to explore how to address an insurance offer that seems too low, call us at (813) 445-8161 for a free consultation.

Get A Free Consultation