When Drinks Lead to Disaster: Can a Bar or Restaurant Be Held Liable for Overserving a Drunk Driver?

After a drunk driving accident, the primary focus when considering fault lands on the intoxicated driver. Yet, other parties sometimes contribute to the tragedy. In specific circumstances, a bar or restaurant may be held liable for overserving a drunk driver.

Establishments that provide alcohol do face responsibility under dram shop laws.

Get A Free Consultation

Dram Shop Laws

Dram shop laws address an establishment’s accountability for alcohol-related harm. These laws recognize that businesses selling alcohol have a duty to do so responsibly. They sometimes answer for the resulting damages if they fail in this duty.

Dram shop laws allow victims of drunk driving accidents to pursue claims against third-party vendors like bars, restaurants, or liquor stores. These businesses might have irresponsibly served alcohol to the person who caused the accident.

These laws vary from state to state. Both Washington and Florida have versions of these laws. In Florida, an establishment is generally not at fault for the actions of a drunk driver, unless it served a minor or someone who is habitually addicted to alcohol.

In Washington, establishments are prohibited from serving visibly drunk people and may be held accountable if they serve someone who drunkenly creates an accident.

When Establishments Might Be Accountable

In many states, an establishment might be accountable if it serves alcohol to someone who is already visibly intoxicated. It might also face liability for serving alcohol to a minor. The key is whether the service was negligent or unlawful.

This negligence or unlawful service must then link directly to the harm caused by the intoxicated person. Each case depends on its unique facts. A restaurant might be responsible for a drunk driving incident under these conditions.

The presence of these laws means you might have a path to hold an irresponsible bar accountable if you were injured in a drunk driving car crash. A business choosing to sell alcohol accepts certain responsibilities. Failing to meet these responsibilities sometimes has legal consequences.

Signs That an Establishment Overserved a Patron

Identifying overservice is a key part of exploring an establishment’s liability after a drunk driving crash. There are common indicators that bar or restaurant staff might notice, or should notice, that point to a person being visibly intoxicated.

Ignoring these signs often leads to situations where a bar or restaurant is held liable for overserving a drunk driver.

Observable Behaviors

Experienced bar and restaurant staff should recognize signs of intoxication. Some common behaviors include:

• Slurred Speech: Difficulty speaking clearly is a classic indicator of intoxication.
• Stumbling or Poor Coordination: Trouble walking, swaying, or fumbling with objects signals impairment.
• Aggressive or Boisterous Conduct: A sudden change to loud, disruptive, or confrontational behavior is frequently linked to excessive alcohol consumption.

Observing these signs suggests a patron has had too much alcohol, and continued service at this point raises questions about the bar’s liability. If a server notices these issues, continuing to provide alcohol makes the vendor part of the problem if that patron later drives.

Visibly Intoxicated

Many dram shop laws use a “visibly intoxicated” or “apparently intoxicated” standard, which means the patron showed clear outward signs of being drunk when the establishment served them their last drink.

Proving someone met this standard often relies on witness testimony, including other patrons, staff members, or even police officers who interacted with the driver.

Evidence might also come from receipts showing a large amount of alcohol served to one person over a short time. Security camera footage, if available, is also very helpful.

Meeting this standard is often a central point in a claim asking if a bar or restaurant can be held liable for overserving a drunk driver.

Serving Minors

Serving alcohol to minors is a serious offense, and there are strict rules in many states, including Washington and Florida. If a bar or restaurant serves alcohol to someone underage, and that minor then causes a drunk driving accident, the establishment’s liability is often easier to establish.

Simply providing alcohol to a minor who then causes harm is often enough for the establishment to be accountable. Businesses selling alcohol have a strong duty to check identification, and failure to do so makes them vulnerable to a claim.

Available Compensation in a Dram Shop Case

If a bar or restaurant is found liable for overserving a drunk driver, the compensation available is similar to that of other personal injury claims. The goal is to cover the losses and harm you suffered due to the accident. While each case is different, potential areas of compensation might include:

• Medical Expenses: This covers everything from emergency room visits and hospital stays to ongoing physical therapy and future medical needs.
• Lost Income: If the injuries prevented you from working, you might recover lost wages and compensation for diminished future earning capacity.
• Property Damage: This compensation is for repairs or replacement of your vehicle or other damaged property.
• Pain and Suffering: This payment addresses the physical pain, emotional distress, and diminished quality of life resulting from the accident.
• Loss of Consortium: A spouse may be able to recover damages for the loss of companionship, support, and affection resulting from the injury to their loved one.
• Punitive Damages: In cases of egregious or reckless conduct by the establishment, additional damages may be awarded to punish the wrongdoer and deter similar behavior.

Time Limits for Filing a Claim

States have laws called statutes of limitations that set deadlines for filing lawsuits. If you miss this deadline, you usually lose your right to sue.

These time limits also apply to claims against a bar or restaurant for overserving a drunk driver. The exact deadline varies by state and the specifics of the case.

You need to act promptly because gathering evidence and building a strong case takes time. Contact a legal professional to learn about the specific time limit that applies to your situation.

How a Lawyer Helps With Dram Shop Claims

Dealing with the aftermath of a drunk driving accident is difficult, and when you suspect a bar or restaurant also played a role by overserving the driver, the situation becomes more complex.

A lawyer experienced in these types of cases offers valuable assistance. They manage the legal challenges while you focus on recovery.

Investigating the Establishment’s Involvement

Lawyers know what to look for in dram shop cases and conduct detailed investigations into the circumstances of the accident and the events leading up to it. This includes identifying the establishment where the drunk driver consumed alcohol.

They gather information about the driver’s behavior at the bar and the bar’s serving practices and history. This comprehensive investigation is fundamental to building a robust, evidence-based claim.

Gathering Necessary Evidence

Proving that a bar or restaurant is liable for overserving requires evidence. Your attorney knows how to obtain this proof. They might seek:

• Witness Statements: Testimony from other patrons, bar staff, or anyone who saw the driver being served while visibly intoxicated strengthens your claim.
• Police Reports and Chemical Test Results: These documents provide official information about the accident and the driver’s level of intoxication.
• Bar Records and Surveillance Footage: Receipts, credit card statements, and security video often show how much alcohol was served and the patron’s condition.

This evidence helps build a strong argument that the establishment knew, or should have known, the patron was intoxicated but continued serving them.

Navigating Complex Legal Processes

Dram shop laws are specific and vary by state. An attorney understands these laws and handles all the legal paperwork and procedures. This includes filing the claim correctly and meeting all deadlines. Your attorney represents your interests and can explain each step of the process to you in clear language.

Dealing With Insurance Companies

Bars and restaurants usually have liability insurance. Their insurance company will defend against your claim. Insurance adjusters often try to minimize payouts or deny responsibility altogether. Your lawyer acts as your advocate, handling all communications with the insurance companies.

They protect you from tactics designed to undervalue your claim about the restaurant’s responsibility for the drunk driving accident.

Calculating Fair Compensation

Determining the full value of your claim isn’t always simple. It involves more than just current medical bills. Your lawyer assesses all your damages, including future medical needs, lost earning capacity, physical pain, and emotional suffering.

They work to make certain that any demand for compensation reflects the true impact the accident has had on your life. This detailed calculation supports your quest for fair payment if a bar is liable for the drunk driver’s actions.

Representing You in Negotiations (or Court)

Most personal injury claims, including those involving an establishment’s liability for overserving, resolve through negotiation. Lawyers are skilled negotiators and can present the evidence and argue on your behalf to reach a fair settlement.

If a settlement is impossible, your lawyer can take your case to court and fight to hold the negligent bar or restaurant accountable.

FAQ for Can a Bar or Restaurant Be Held Liable for Overserving a Drunk Driver?

How Do I Know if a Bar Illegally Served the Drunk Driver?

Determining if a bar illegally served the drunk driver often requires investigation. Visible signs include serving someone already stumbling, slurring their speech, or acting aggressively.

If the driver was a minor and was served, that’s also an illegal sale in most cases. An attorney helps uncover evidence, like witness accounts or bar security footage.

What if the Bar Says the Driver Was Already Drunk When They Arrived?

Even if a person consumed alcohol before coming to the bar, the establishment might still be liable if they served them more alcohol while the person was visibly intoxicated. The bar’s staff has a duty to refuse service to patrons who already show clear signs of drunkenness.

Does Suing a Bar Affect My Case Against the Drunk Driver?

Generally, pursuing a claim against a bar doesn’t prevent you from also suing the drunk driver. These are typically separate but related claims, and in many situations, both the driver and the establishment that overserved them share responsibility for the harm caused.

A lawyer can advise you on the best strategy for handling both aspects of your case.

What if the Bar Claims That They Followed All the Rules?

Bars sometimes deny wrongdoing and claim they followed responsible serving practices. However, a thorough investigation might reveal evidence to the contrary.

Witness testimony, video footage, or even their own employees’ statements might show they did serve a visibly intoxicated person or a minor. Your lawyer’s job is to look beyond these initial denials.

Can I Still Make a Claim if the Drunk Driver Fled the Scene After the Accident?

Yes, you might still make a claim against a bar or restaurant for overserving, even if the drunk driver fled the accident scene. The establishment’s liability focuses on its irresponsible service.

While a hit-and-run complicates the police investigation of the driver, your attorney still investigates the bar’s role in the intoxication leading to the crash.

Pursue Justice With Boohoff Law, P.A.

The road to physical and emotional recovery after an accident is challenging, but holding all responsible parties accountable is a step towards finding closure and security.

If a drunk driver injured you or a loved one, and you suspect a bar or restaurant irresponsibly served them, explore your legal options. The dedicated team at Boohoff Law, P.A. is ready to listen to your story.

Contact Boohoff Law, P.A., at (813) 445-8161 for a free, no-obligation consultation to learn about your rights and how we can assist.

Get A Free Consultation